Thursday, August 27, 2009

Who'll pay for IVF in Ontario (and elsewhere)?

Recently, an interesting proposal was made regarding a new service to be covered by OHIP, Ontario's public health insurance plan.

The Ontario government should provide funding for up to three cycles of in vitro fertilization for women under the age of 42, according to a report released Wednesday.

An expert panel on infertility and adoption, appointed by Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty last summer, is also recommending replacing a "patchwork" of adoption services with a centralized adoption agency.

One in six couples will struggle with infertility and the greatest barrier to assisted reproduction services is the cost, with one cycle of IVF costing about $10,000, according to the panel.

The group said the high cost of fertility treatments is leading to decisions which result in an unacceptably high rate of multiple births in Ontario.

To increase chances of success, women and couples choose to have more than one embryo transferred, say the authors of the report. As a result, the rate of multiple births from assisted reproduction was 27.5 per cent in 2006, compared to rates below 10 per cent in other jurisdictions with controls on the number of embryos transferred, they say.

This plan is relatively controversial, given Ontario's own budgetary problems and concerns over strains on the healthcare system.

[The report] points to other jurisdictions that have used public funding as a mechanism to reduce multi-births and argues this saves money down the road by avoiding medical complications from twins and triplets.

But counting on those (imputed) savings requires a leap of faith. It may not fully account for the possibility that many other couples would line up for IVF at public expense – crowding out a strained health budget. In any case, if multiple implantations are medically unsound, they ought to be banned on medical grounds; it's not clear that the province should use its chequebook to discourage what it could otherwise accomplish through regulation and standards of practice.

Welcoming the report, Premier Dalton McGuinty expressed sympathy for families but warned that Ontario faces difficult economic times. That is a good place to start an informed public debate.

The question of government funding for fertility treatments has been a notable issue, triggering lawsuits against the provincial government.

In Quebec, high-profile TV personality Julie Snyder, the wife of Quebecor CEO Pierre-Karl Péladeau, urged the province to cover IVF treatments. She made a documentary about infertility and put pressure on politicians.

In April, Premier Jean Charest's government announced that it will fund three IVF cycles for couples, making Quebec the only province to do so.

Seang Lin Tan, a fertility expert at the McGill University Health Centre in Montreal, said one in eight Canadian couples struggles with infertility.

"What's frustrating, is that people who would be good candidates are routinely told they have to dig into their pockets," Prof. Attaran said. "I'm fortunate, law professors get paid decently. But that's not true for everyone."

After a year of trying to conceive, the couple paid $6,300 for one IVF treatment at an Ottawa fertility clinic. A further $6,500 in drugs was covered by private insurance.

A spokesperson for Ontario Health Minister David Caplan said he would not comment on the case.

OHIP paid for IVF in the past, but in a cost-cutting measure in 1994, Ontario withdrew funding except for women whose fallopian tubes are blocked. That applies to about 25 per cent of infertile patients, said Jeff Nisker, a professor of obstetrics, gynecology and oncology at the University of Western Ontario.

Just to the northeast, it should be noted that Québec has adopted a policy of subsidizing fertility treatments, first offering a refundable tax credit paying for 50% of the costs of the treatment up to a maximum of $C 10 000 and now preparing to fund the first three cycles of in vitro fertility treatments. This, it should be noted, is part of a historic policy on Québec's part of heavily subsidizing parents and their children.

Since 1997, the province has implemented a panoply of measures to support women who want to be good mothers without sacrificing their careers.

They include generous parental leave, affordable child care, tax incentives for child-bearing, and employment premiums for working parents.

They appear to have worked: Twelve years ago, the province's fertility rate stood at 1.51 children per woman. Today it stands at a 30-year high of 1.72 children per woman, significantly higher than the Canadian average of 1.58.

Premier Jean Charest calls his province "a paradise for families." He boasts that Quebec has succeeded in slowing its population decline, reducing child poverty and increasing the employment rate among women.

His government plans to go further, offering public funding to infertile couples who want in vitro fertilization.

Quebec's programs are expensive. The province will spend $6.5 billion to support families this year (45 per cent more than Ontario).

But its fertility rate is on par with those of the Scandinavian countries, the Netherlands and Britain.

Critics call Quebec's approach costly social engineering. But the majority of citizens support their government's family policies because they make life easier for parents and safeguard the province's francophone identify.

No other government in the country is following Quebec's example.

In covering this issue, many journalists have noted that in addition to Québec, countries like Belgium, Sweden, Australia, and Israel all pay the costs of at least several cycles of in vitro fertilization. I wonder if the number of countries providing fertility treatments will grow, perhaps driven by concerns over population issues as they effect national populations and national power. Certainly Australia and Israel have histories of wanting to boost their populations, motivated by concerns for these nation's continued survival.

At any rate, the question of assisted reproductive technologies and how they'll be used in different societies is sure to be a major issue, not least because of the continued increase in the age of women at their first child. The women might be blamed for their acting in non-traditional roles, and stigma surrounding male infertility will continue to some degree, but these technologies will continue to be used. In countries with any kind of health insurance program, the emotive question of whether or not aspiring parents will be supported in their desire to have children will continue to be asked.


Unknown said...

The Economist: The baby bonanza

chris said...

Malhotra Test Tube Baby and IVF Clinic in India provides IVF Treatments which includes IVF ICSI IUI Treatment Cost in India, Embryo Donation, Egg Donation, infertility treatment, Male Female Infertility Treatment India

Dr.Narendra Malhotra said...

Malhotra Test Tube Baby and IVF Clinic in India provides IVF Treatments which includes IVF ICSI IUI Treatment Cost in India, Embryo Donation, Egg Donation, infertility treatment, Male Female Infertility Treatment India.

selectsurrogacyblog said...

India offers clear grounds for Surrogacy Legalities At Affordable Cost with best Surrogacy Procedure and IVF treatment you can think of.We have a very simple business model that keeps intended parents at the centre.Having the industry's most elaborate and exclusive Patient Care and Clinical Coordination teams with our Clinic, we provide you the smoothest and seamless surrogacy care you ever imagined in India.
Surrogacy agencies in India
Gestational Surrogacy in India
Cost Infertility Treatment in India
Best IVF Doctor in Delhi India

Ranbeer singh said...

Kiran Infertility Center is a Super Specialty Facility dealing in Infertility Treatments and Surrogacy in India. An ISO 9001- 2008 Company, with its cutting-edge technology, world-renowned experts and a patient-centric approach, has been a dominant player in the area of Fertility Treatments and is one of the oldest surrogacy clinics in Hyderabad and Secunderabad offering IVF Surrogacy in India.

buy silymarin 140 mg online silymarin 140 mg said...

Silymarin Used to protect liver cells (and other cells in the body and brain) from toxins. - Silymarin promotes liver cell protein synthesis and decreases the oxidation of glutathione.

Modvigil 200 said...

Modvigil 200 Modafinil is used to treat excessive sleepiness caused by narcolepsy (a condition that causes excessive daytime sleepiness) or shift work sleep disorder.

Modalert 200 is considered one of the most effective treatments among all other drugs for improving wakefulness and cognitive function in patients with excessive daytime sleepiness. Modalert 200 contains Modafinil, a prescription medicine that belongs to a class of drugs called eugeroics or wakefulness-promoting agents.

Ziverdo Kit is a set of three types of medication -zinc acetate 50 mg, Doxycycline 100mg, Ivermectin 12mg. Active Ingredient Zinc acetate (50mg) + Doxycycline (100mg) + Ivermectin (12mg) Features Of Ziverdo kit Zinc acetate 50 mg, Ivermectin 12mg, Doxycycline 100mg, Let us now analyze each component

Generic viagra online said...

Super-P-Force is an excellent combination of powerful drugs like Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. This drug combination is highly effective in relieving erectile dysfunction and even premature ejaculation. Super P Force has unbelievably helped several men combating premature ejaculation and ED disorders. This drug consists of an active component Sildenafil Citrate 100mg and Dapoxetine 60 mg which delays ejaculations and also provide erection for suffice time.
Extra Super P Force 200mg is a new form of hybrid combination treatment for erectile dysfunction and premature ejaculation. Containing the active ingredients Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine, patients can experience a healthy erection and more control over the length of intercourse. Dapoxetine is clinically proven and approved in many countries to treat premature ejaculation and allows intercourse to last longer.
The active ingredients of Super P-force are Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. Sildenfil Citrate belongs to the PDE-5 family of vasodilators.

Super P Force Oral Jelly is an excellent combination of powerful drugs like Sildenafil Citrate and Dapoxetine. This drug combination is highly effective in relieving erectile dysfunction and even premature ejaculation. Super P Force has unbelievably helped several men combating premature ejaculation and ED disorders. This drug consists of an active component Sildenafil Citrate 100mg and Dapoxetine 60 mg which delays ejaculations and also provide erection for suffice time.

Buy Kamagra Online said...

Aurogra 100 may be a drug containing Sildenafil citrate. It's the cure for one of the foremost commonly occurring sexual disorders by men. It is a potent medication that came as a spell for patients with impotence or male erecticle dysfunction.

Extra Super tadarise can be used to treat erectile problems and early climax. Premature ejaculation and impotence are both performance issues that can affect sexual satisfaction. Two active ingredients are combined in Extra Super Tadarise to address both of these issues.

Malegra The essential dynamic segment of Malegra is Sildenafil Citrate . It is this that helps men who are weak, yet sexually aroused, to get a stiffer hard on, that causes them last more while engaging in sexual relations. Malegra is a very high-quality generic adaptation of Sildenafil Citrate, and it gives the user all the advantages related with the original item – at a much lower cost. malegra take under registered medical practice only.

Vidalista said...

Vidalista 20 belongs to the PDE-5 depletion type of drugs which is helpful in suppressing the signs of erectile dysfunction. The main purpose of this drug is to resolve any issues being faced by the men during intercourse.
Vidalista 40 mg is a generic variant of Cialis. It ensures a long-lasting erection that can last up to 36 hours! This is why Vidalista is often called the weekend pill. In case of sexual stimulation, the penis will stiffen easily. Also, the side effects are not that severe thanks to the low dosage.For men who want to be guaranteed for a prolonged period of time,

Vidalista 60 Tadalafil 60 mg has an active ingredient called Tadalafil. Which is a medicine that relaxes the muscles in gore vessel walls thus improving blood flow to certain body parts, and it is this action that makes the medicine efficient in treating erectile dysfunction. Vidalista 60 is also used to treat symptoms of benign prostatic pyperplasia, which improves the ability to exercise in those with pulmonary arterial hypertension. This product also comes in 20 mg, 40 mg, and an 80 mg form

Fildena said...

Kamagra Oral Jelly is an oral medication that is used to treat erectile dysfunction in men. It is an oral tablet with the active ingredient sildenafil citrate, one of the most popular ED treatments. Sexual desire is the basic need of everyone, and if it's not fulfilled in a marriage, it leads to conflicts that finally end up in the relationship.

Fildena 100 is the ultimate solution for the ones who experience any issues with sexual health like sexual impotency. Erectile dysfunction is the most common problem amongst men all around the world. If anyone suffering from such issues is still looking for a permanent solution to end the trouble. Then Fildena 100 is the right choice for it. Here you will get all the needed information to help with the treatment of erectile dysfunction and increasing blood flow to the area to resolve all issues.

Fildena 150 mg tablet consist sildenafil citrate which is PDE type of 5 is inhibitor cGMP into vein and that is increase the blood flow into vein.

Cenforce said...

Cenforce 100 (sildenafil citrate) Known as a Blue pill, Sildenafil citrate helps to treats Sexual impotence in men, Cenforce 100 (Blue pill) helps to increasing blood flow in the penile to helps a man get harder and keep a long time an erection.
Cenforce 150 mg is one of the medicines which is used to treat Erectile Dysfunction (ED) or impotence in men. The doctors may prescribe Cenforce 150 mg Sildenafil in some cases for the symptoms of pulmonary hypertension. Cenforce 200 is an incredible drug that is used to cure Erectile Dysfunction.

Originelle said...

I have gone through your entire blog. When I started to read it, I just went on and on.
Wonderful blog. I love this. Thanks. Hopefully, you keep on producing more such blogs. Plz, have a look at best IVF clinic in Ottawa @

anna joy said...

Aurogra 100 is very similar to the well-known drug, Viagra. This medication's main ingredient would be sildenafil citrate. The drug is one of the most commonly used to treat impotence. This drug has been approved by the FDA and it is safe to take.
Read more:
Kamagra Gold
Fildena 150