Thursday, August 27, 2009

Who'll pay for IVF in Ontario (and elsewhere)?

Recently, an interesting proposal was made regarding a new service to be covered by OHIP, Ontario's public health insurance plan.

The Ontario government should provide funding for up to three cycles of in vitro fertilization for women under the age of 42, according to a report released Wednesday.

An expert panel on infertility and adoption, appointed by Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty last summer, is also recommending replacing a "patchwork" of adoption services with a centralized adoption agency.

One in six couples will struggle with infertility and the greatest barrier to assisted reproduction services is the cost, with one cycle of IVF costing about $10,000, according to the panel.

The group said the high cost of fertility treatments is leading to decisions which result in an unacceptably high rate of multiple births in Ontario.

To increase chances of success, women and couples choose to have more than one embryo transferred, say the authors of the report. As a result, the rate of multiple births from assisted reproduction was 27.5 per cent in 2006, compared to rates below 10 per cent in other jurisdictions with controls on the number of embryos transferred, they say.


This plan is relatively controversial, given Ontario's own budgetary problems and concerns over strains on the healthcare system.

[The report] points to other jurisdictions that have used public funding as a mechanism to reduce multi-births and argues this saves money down the road by avoiding medical complications from twins and triplets.

But counting on those (imputed) savings requires a leap of faith. It may not fully account for the possibility that many other couples would line up for IVF at public expense – crowding out a strained health budget. In any case, if multiple implantations are medically unsound, they ought to be banned on medical grounds; it's not clear that the province should use its chequebook to discourage what it could otherwise accomplish through regulation and standards of practice.

Welcoming the report, Premier Dalton McGuinty expressed sympathy for families but warned that Ontario faces difficult economic times. That is a good place to start an informed public debate.


The question of government funding for fertility treatments has been a notable issue, triggering lawsuits against the provincial government.

In Quebec, high-profile TV personality Julie Snyder, the wife of Quebecor CEO Pierre-Karl Péladeau, urged the province to cover IVF treatments. She made a documentary about infertility and put pressure on politicians.

In April, Premier Jean Charest's government announced that it will fund three IVF cycles for couples, making Quebec the only province to do so.

Seang Lin Tan, a fertility expert at the McGill University Health Centre in Montreal, said one in eight Canadian couples struggles with infertility.

"What's frustrating, is that people who would be good candidates are routinely told they have to dig into their pockets," Prof. Attaran said. "I'm fortunate, law professors get paid decently. But that's not true for everyone."

After a year of trying to conceive, the couple paid $6,300 for one IVF treatment at an Ottawa fertility clinic. A further $6,500 in drugs was covered by private insurance.

A spokesperson for Ontario Health Minister David Caplan said he would not comment on the case.

OHIP paid for IVF in the past, but in a cost-cutting measure in 1994, Ontario withdrew funding except for women whose fallopian tubes are blocked. That applies to about 25 per cent of infertile patients, said Jeff Nisker, a professor of obstetrics, gynecology and oncology at the University of Western Ontario.


Just to the northeast, it should be noted that Québec has adopted a policy of subsidizing fertility treatments, first offering a refundable tax credit paying for 50% of the costs of the treatment up to a maximum of $C 10 000 and now preparing to fund the first three cycles of in vitro fertility treatments. This, it should be noted, is part of a historic policy on Québec's part of heavily subsidizing parents and their children.

Since 1997, the province has implemented a panoply of measures to support women who want to be good mothers without sacrificing their careers.

They include generous parental leave, affordable child care, tax incentives for child-bearing, and employment premiums for working parents.

They appear to have worked: Twelve years ago, the province's fertility rate stood at 1.51 children per woman. Today it stands at a 30-year high of 1.72 children per woman, significantly higher than the Canadian average of 1.58.

Premier Jean Charest calls his province "a paradise for families." He boasts that Quebec has succeeded in slowing its population decline, reducing child poverty and increasing the employment rate among women.

His government plans to go further, offering public funding to infertile couples who want in vitro fertilization.

Quebec's programs are expensive. The province will spend $6.5 billion to support families this year (45 per cent more than Ontario).

But its fertility rate is on par with those of the Scandinavian countries, the Netherlands and Britain.

Critics call Quebec's approach costly social engineering. But the majority of citizens support their government's family policies because they make life easier for parents and safeguard the province's francophone identify.

No other government in the country is following Quebec's example.


In covering this issue, many journalists have noted that in addition to Québec, countries like Belgium, Sweden, Australia, and Israel all pay the costs of at least several cycles of in vitro fertilization. I wonder if the number of countries providing fertility treatments will grow, perhaps driven by concerns over population issues as they effect national populations and national power. Certainly Australia and Israel have histories of wanting to boost their populations, motivated by concerns for these nation's continued survival.

At any rate, the question of assisted reproductive technologies and how they'll be used in different societies is sure to be a major issue, not least because of the continued increase in the age of women at their first child. The women might be blamed for their acting in non-traditional roles, and stigma surrounding male infertility will continue to some degree, but these technologies will continue to be used. In countries with any kind of health insurance program, the emotive question of whether or not aspiring parents will be supported in their desire to have children will continue to be asked.

29 comments:

Nobody said...

The Economist: The baby bonanza

Originelle said...

I have gone through your entire blog. When I started to read it, I just went on and on.
Wonderful blog. I love this. Thanks. Hopefully, you keep on producing more such blogs. Plz, have a look at best IVF clinic in Ottawa @ https://originelle.com/contact-us/clinic-in-ottawa.html


Oliviagarcia said...

Fildena is also known for its ability to help men all over the world get erections and keep them for longer periods of time. Inability to have sexual relations, also referred to as erectile dysfunction, is an issue that affects men around the world every day. The world over, men use Fildena 150 pills hard in order to fight their sexual interactions and have a lasting sexual experience. As a result, the blood flows freely because the blood vessels dilate and obstructions in the arteries are removed. This facilitates smooth blood flow through the penis. This means that the penis is filled with blood and becomes hard and erect for longer that is not the norm. This allows you to enjoy the pleasures of intimacy with your partner , permitting you to remain longer in sexual activity.
Read More:
Cenforce 100
Cenforce 200
Aurogra 100
Malegra

Anonymous said...


Is it too costly to buy organic food at farmer’s markets? Continue reading to find out how to avoid relying on people for your fruits and vegetables by developing and maintaining your own home organic gardening full of tasty produce! Sod should be correctly laid.

One of the simplest methods for most nutritious vegetables for juicing to meet your daily nutritional intake. Store-bought juice is frequently pricey and contains preservatives that make it less healthy. This article will teach you how to make your own juice from fresh fruits and vegetables.

Do you want to tips for cooking with new, fun, and exciting menu ideas? You are, of course! top cooking tips for here Here. We want to broaden your culinary horizons by trying out all-new recipes and methods. Let’s discuss some great ways to get creative in the kitchen.allaccessblog

medsplus said...

thearticlestream
back pain on left side
do dogs get tired of barking

This article will tell you about many articles and blogs related to various varieties.

nandhiniblog said...

Thank you for sharing this.Hysupplies offer Soft, Smooth, and Durable  Hospital Blankets. If interested, Please visit hysupplies.net

skipperoo1 said...

fildena 100mg, is the ultimate answer for those who are experiencing sexual health difficulties such as sexual impotency. Erectile dysfunction is the most frequent condition among males worldwide. If you are still seeking a lasting solution to your problem, here is the place to be.

Cenforce 100mg, is an erectile dysfunction medication. Cenforce 100mg tablet is often referred to as the "blue pill" for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). It allows the user to experience orgasm while experiencing sexual excitement. This is a fast and simple method of treating sexual dysfunction.

Vidalista 20mg, is a PDE-5 depletion medicine that aids in the suppression of erectile dysfunction symptoms. The primary goal of this medicine is to address any concerns that men may have during intercourse. It mostly acts by boosting blood flow to the phallus. Erectile dysfunction may be a serious issue in a man's life at any age.

skipperoo1 said...

Cenforce 100 reviews, is an erectile dysfunction medication. Cenforce 100mg tablet is often referred to as the "blue pill" for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). It allows the user to experience orgasm while experiencing sexual excitement. This is a fast and simple method of treating sexual dysfunction.

skipperoo1 said...

Vidalista 20 reviews, is a PDE-5 depletion medicine that aids in the suppression of erectile dysfunction symptoms. The primary goal of this medicine is to address any concerns that men may have during intercourse. It mostly acts by boosting blood flow to the phallus. Erectile dysfunction may be a serious issue in a man's life at any age.

skipperoo1 said...


fildena 100 reviews, is the ultimate answer for those who are experiencing sexual health difficulties such as sexual impotency. Erectile dysfunction is the most frequent condition among males worldwide. If you are still seeking a lasting solution to your problem, here is the place to be

Tadalista said...

Tadalista 60 mg mg pill is used for the purpose of relieving the symptoms of erectile dysfunction(ED) or impotence in men if it is caused due to poor blood circulation and related conditions. You take one Tadalista 60 mg tablet about 45-60 min before you want the Tadalista 60 to be active in your body, and it should be active in about 35-40 minutes, after that you will have 36 hours of its power at your disposal. Tadalista 20 price is an oral ED pills that is used for the treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED) in men. Buy Tadalista 40 mg online at the cheapest rate from Sildenafilcitrates.com
The higher doses of Tadalafil, for example, Tadalista 60 mg are just used for the treatment of erectile dysfunction(ED) as pills or pills which are taken just when required. This conversely, with the lower dose, for example, Tadalista 5 mg and Tadalista 10 mg, which are utilized and recommended daily medicines of erectile dysfunction(ED).

Vidalista 60 safe said...

Buy Vidalista 60 online in the USA at the best costs. It is one of the most selling ED medication that is high effective in treating men impotence conditions.
What is Vidalista 60?
Vidalista 60 mg is an oral pill used to treating a male sexual issue called erectile dysfunction or weakness. Tadalafil is the significant active element of this ED medication. This ED pill has a place with the PDE5 inhibitor class of medications that normally increase the blood stream component and make gentler erections. Other than treating ED, Vidalista 20 additionally boost to help male sexual execution.
Active component of Vidalista 40 is Tadalafil which works for relaxing the veins and augmentation the circulatory system to explicit body parts. Tadalafil under the name Cialis is supposed to fix erectile dysfunction (ED) in men and cautiously not endorsed to women.
Vidalista Dosage - certified by FDA and made by Centurion Lab in India is an exhibited drug to treat ED in around a day and a half.

Anonymous said...

Aspadol 100mg (Tapentadol) tablet used to treat relieve moderate to severe short-term pain, enough to require opioid treatment and when other pain medicines did not work well enough or cannot be tolerated. It works in the brain to change how your body feels and responds to pain.


Prosoma 500mg (carisoprodol), also known as Soma. It is a muscle relaxant that reduces pain sensations between the nerves and the brain. Soma is used to treating bone and muscular disorders such as pain or injury, as well as rest and physical therapy.

Genericshub said...

Pain o Soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain o Soma is used together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.


Tapaday 200mg Tablet is a medication used to treat moderate to severe acute pain. It treats many conditions such as headache, fever, menstrual pain, toothache, and cold, and it effectively eases pain when other treatments fail to relieve it.

skipperoo1 said...


pain o soma (carisoprodol) is commonly used as a muscle relaxant. The medicine works by preventing pain sensations from being transmitted between the brain and nerves. Pain relievers such as Soma 500mg are required, as well as rest and physical rehabilitation.

Tapentadol, the main component in aspadol tablets, is a narcotic pain medication that is also used to treat all sorts of moderate to severe pain.

pain management said...

Pain O Soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is a muscle relaxant that works by blocking pain signals between the nerves and the brain. Pain o Soma is used together with rest and physical therapy to treat skeletal muscle conditions such as pain or injury.

Trustablepills said...

Cenforce 100 drug is utilized for the treatment of male erection issues. Cenforce 100mg accompanies the conventional name of sildenafil citrate in the portion strength of 100mg.

skipperoo1 said...

Pain O Soma 500mg (carisoprodol) is often used as a muscle relaxant. The drug works by preventing painful sensations from being transmitted between the brain and the nerves. Pain relievers like Soma 500mg are needed, as well as rest and physical rejuvenation.

Lorigail said...

Filitra 20 medicine contains Vardenafil, which is a phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE5) inhibitor. This component is used to treat erectile dysfunction in men (impotence). When the pill is consumed before planned sexual activity, the pill inhibits the breakdown (by the enzyme PDE5) of a chemical known as cGMP. The action of the medicine allows blood flow into the penile causing an erection.


Filitra 10

Genericshub said...

aspadol 100mg (Tapentadol) is used to treat moderate to severe short term pain, such as pain from an injury or after surgery. It is used to treat moderate to severe musculoskeletal pain, both acute and chronic. It is also specifically approved for treating the pain of diabetic neuropathy when opioid medicine is necessary 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

somaboost 750mg (Carisoprodol) is the best pain killer and muscle relaxant tablet. Soma relaxes your skeletal muscles and heals your muscle pain.

Weed said...

Everything revolves around benefits, not highlights. Doug finds a modest wellspring of clinical maryjane in a center in LA and believes he's found a mother lode.
Online Dispensary Canada

Carlingford Chiropractic said...

Do you see the similarity to this lower back torment work out? Indeed, it looks like swimming. Swimming is by a long shot the best activity; notice how swimmers seldom have back muscle issues?
Carlingford Chiropractic

Ryde Chiropractor said...

A fair warning: Do not do these activities in the event that you are not as of now taking part in an activity program. Additionally, kindly check with your doctor before you start any activity program.
Ryde Chiropractor

Taylor said...

Cenforce 150mg is a medicine used to treat erectile dysfunction. Cenforce 150mg tablet is popularly known as the red pill for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). It enables the user to reach orgasm during sexual arousal. This is a quick and easy way to treat sexual dysfunction.

Genericshub is one of the most trusted online pharmaceutical companies across the world. Our aim is to provide pure medicines to our customers.Fildena 100mg, kamagra oral jelly, Super p force

Buymedlife said...

The most potent generic drug, Fildena 100mg, is primarily used to treat male erection issues known as erectile dysfunctions (ED).
Increase blood flow to the genital regions and relax blood vessel muscle to treat erectile dysfunction.


To be more specific, Vidalista 80mg is a tablet that belongs to the Tadalafil family of PDE-5 hormone suppressing medications. You may get erect and be supported for a considerable amount of time by ingesting Vidalista 80 mg, which is regarded as an extraordinarily high dosage.

PillSuppliers said...

nice.

ivermectin24store said...

Why You Should Contemplate Ziverdo Package?
As a result of speedy enhance within the Covid 19 sufferers, it's important to get vaccinated on your safety, together with correct prescribed medicines of Covid. Right this moment on this article, you’ll get to know some precious insights concerning the Ziverdo Package pill that you will need to know earlier than its consumption.
Ziverdo Kit is the first remedy for all Covid constructive sufferers, whereas it's a triple mixture of energetic medicine united in all of the profitable doses. It accommodates three important components that are Doxycycline 100mg, zinc acetate 50mg, and Ivermectin 12 mg Dispersible tablets. When speaking about Zinc acetate, 50 mg significantly aids in treating numerous liver illnesses as, because of this, it induces to devour a considerable amount of copper from meals. Subsequently should be taken in correct doses as really helpful by your physician.
As well as, there are a number of widespread negative effects that you simply may expertise with this medicine, equivalent to indigestion, Nausea, and extra. In such circumstances, it's important to inform your doctor if the negative effects final for an extended interval.


buy ivermectin for humans | ziverdo kit | hydroxychloroquine | ciprofloxacin dosage | plaquenil

RSM Enterprises said...

Extra Super M Force helps men overcome the challenges of ED by providing a reliable and robust erection.

Buy Sildenafil & Dapoxetine Tablets
Order Now +91 92163-25377

ishan said...

Before using aurogra 100 mg, it is crucial to consult with a healthcare professional, especially for those with pre-existing medical conditions or taking other medications.